I made these pick orders as an exercise for myself when I was seriously trying to beat TSE drafts. I am probably done drafting that set more than every once in a while, so I figured I'd post my orders.

There are probably a few places where I put a card in a spot it didn't deserve, because ranking Echo Chamber vs Phyrexian Grimoire just doesn't matter, but it makes the playable cards harder to place correctly. The --------- lines basically mean that I don't play the cards below the line unless something went wrong, so I don't really care which is better, though I still tried to rank them appropriately.

Tempest White
[deck]Master Decoy
Pacifism
Soltari Trooper
Soltari Lancer
Cloudchaser Eagle
Advance Scout
Mounted Archers
Elite Javelineer
Clergy en-Vec
Soltari Foot Soldier
Anoint
Hero's Resolve
-------
Circle of Protection: Shadow
Circle of Protection: Black
Circle of Protection: Green
Circle of Protection: Red
Circle of Protection: Blue
Circle of Protection: White
Disenchant
Talon Sliver
Armored Pegasus

Angelic Protector
Knight of Dawn
Repentance
Soltari Monk
Soltari Crusader
Staunch Defenders
Soltari Priest
Light of Day
Quickening Licid
Armor Sliver
Flickering Ward
Gallantry
-------
Serene Offering
Worthy Cause
Warmth
Orim's Prayer
Invulnerability

Avenging Angel
Winds of Rath
Soltari Emissary
Gerrard's Battle Cry
Orim, Samite Healer
Oracle en-Vec
Marble Titan
Spirit Mirror
Safeguard
Humility
Pegasus Refuge
Field of Souls
-------
Sacred Guide
Auratog
Hanna's Custody[/deck]

Tempest Blue
[deck]Rootwater Hunter
Capsize
Horned Turtle
Gaseous Form
Wind Drake
Shadow Rift
Counterspell
Dream Cache
Thalakos Mistfolk
Sea Monster
Power Sink
Time Ebb
Giant Crab
-------
Thalakos Seer
Thalakos Sentry
Volrath's Curse
Twitch
Spell Blast
Manta Riders
Winged Sliver
Shimmering Wings

Fighting Drake
Legacy's Allure
Propaganda
Thalakos Dreamsower
Wind Dancer
Fylamarid
Skyshroud Condor
Mnemonic Sliver
Legerdemain
Dismiss
-------
Whispers of the Muse
Rootwater Diver
Insight
Chill
Interdict
Steal Enchantment

Mawcor
Tradewind Rider
Escaped Shapeshifter
Meditate
Time Warp
Rootwater Matriarch
Unstable Shapeshifter
Rootwater Shaman
Precognition
Intuition
Benthic Behemoth
-------
Whim of Volrath
Ertai's Meddling
Mana Severance
Duplicity[/deck]

Tempest Black
[deck]Dark Banishing
Dauthi Horror
Dauthi Marauder
Evincar's Justice
Enfeeblement
Gravedigger
Diabolic Edict
Rats of Rath
Dauthi Slayer
Disturbed Burial
Marsh Lurker
Darkling Stalker
Endless Scream
Coercion
Clot Sliver
-------
Spinal Graft
Pit Imp
Blood Pet
Servant of Volrath
Sadistic Glee
Dark Ritual

Reckless Spite
Skyshroud Vampire
Dauthi Mindripper
Dauthi Mercenary
Screeching Harpy
Perish
Dread of Night
Knight of Dusk
Souldrinker
Reanimate
Dauthi Ghoul
Mindwhip Sliver
Leeching Licid
Dauthi Embrace
-------
Rain of Tears
Imps' Taunt
Abandon Hope

Coffin Queen
Maddening Imp
Commander Greven il-Vec
Kezzerdrix
Bounty Hunter
Living Death
Bellowing Fiend
Extinction
Dregs of Sorrow
Fevered Convulsions
Sarcomancy
Minion of the Wastes
Death Pits of Rath
Corpse Dance
Carrionette[/deck]

Tempest Red
[deck]Rolling Thunder
Lightning Blast
Fireslinger
Kindle
Flowstone Giant
Lowland Giant
Canyon Wildcat
Wall of Diffusion
Aftershock
Sandstone Warrior
Mogg Raider
Mogg Fanatic
Lightning Elemental
Blood Frenzy
Stun
Mogg Conscripts
-------
Shatter
Giant Strength
Stone Rain
Heart Sliver
Crown of Flames

Renegade Warlord
Flowstone Salamander
Searing Touch
Opportunist
Tahngarth's Rage
Goblin Bombardment
Barbed Sliver
Boil
Shadowstorm
Enraging Licid
-------
Jackal Pup
Havoc
Wild Wurm
Firefly
Sudden Impact
Mogg Squad
Ancient Runes

Flowstone Wyvern
Magmasaur
Rathi Dragon
Chaotic Goo
Deadshot
Starke of Rath
-------
Tooth and Claw
Shocker
Furnace of Rath
No Quarter
Canyon Drake
Pallimud
Hand to Hand
Scorched Earth
Apocalypse[/deck]

Tempest Green
[deck]Elvish Fury
Trained Armodon
Rootwalla
Skyshroud Troll
Canopy Spider
Seeker of Skybreak
Broken Fall
Heartwood Dryad
Skyshroud Elf
Rampant Growth
Muscle Sliver
Skyshroud Ranger
Respite
-------
Pincher Beetles
Reality Anchor
Rootbreaker Wurm
Tranquility
Spike Drone
Frog Tongue
Bayou Dragonfly
Natural Spring

Overrun
Trumpeting Armodon
Charging Rhino
Heartwood Treefolk
Flailing Drake
Nurturing Licid
Krakilin
Scragnoth
Harrow
Apes of Rath
Choke
Needle Storm
Reap
Horned Sliver
Storm Front
-------
Verdigris
Winter's Grasp

Heartwood Giant
Recycle
Crazed Armodon
Mongrel Pack
Dirtcowl Wurm
Verdant Force
Eladamri, Lord of Leaves
Fugitive Druid
Mirri's Guile
Elven Warhounds
Nature's Revolt
-------
Earthcraft
Eladamri's Vineyard
Root Maze
Aluren[/deck]

Tempest Colorless
[deck]Cursed Scroll
Helm of Possession
Puppet Strings
Torture Chamber
Flowstone Sculpture
Phyrexian Hulk
Telethopter
Bottle Gnomes
Energizer
Maze of Shadows
Coiled Tinviper
Patchwork Gnomes
Stalking Stones
Excavator
Manakin
Magnetic Web
Phyrexian Splicer
-------
Tapped Painlands
Squee's Toy
Ancient Tomb
Medallions
Scroll Rack
Phyrexian Grimiore
Emmessi Tome
Scalding Tongs
Metallic Sliver
Mogg Cannon
Fool's Tome
"Slow" Dual Lands
Static Orb
Echo Chamber
Cold Storage
Grindstone
Altar of Dementia
Jinxed Idol
Thumbscrews
Essence Bottle
Booby Trap
Lotus Petal
Wasteland
Ghost Town[/deck]

Stronghold White
[deck]Spirit en-Kor
Smite
Youthful Knight
Nomads en-Kor
Venerable Monk
Conviction
Bandage
-------
Samite Blessing
Skyshroud Falcon
Change of Heart
Honor Guard

Lancers en-Kor
Calming Licid
Temper
Warrior en-Kor
Wall of Essence
-------
Contemplation
Scapegoat

Warrior Angel
Soltari Champion
Shaman en-Kor
-------
Sacred Ground
Hidden Retreat
Pursuit of Knowledge
Rolling Stones[/deck]

Stronghold Blue
[deck]Mind Games
Sift
Cloud Spirit
Mana Leak
Hammerhead Shark
Spindrift Drake
Dream Prowler
-------
Leap
Tidal Warrior
Tidal Surge
Contempt

Gliding Licid
Wall of Tears
-------
Walking Dream
Rebound
Hesitation
Mask of the Mimic
Ransack

Silver Wyvern
Evacuation
Thalakos Deceiver
Reins of Power
-------
Volrath's Shapeshifter
Intruder Alarm
Dream Halls[/deck]

Stronghold Black
[deck]Death Stroke
Foul Imp
Dungeon Shade
Torment
Morgue Thrull
-------
Serpent Warrior
Cannibalize
Lab Rats
Brush with Death
Rabid Rats
Tortured Existence

Corrupting Licid
Stronghold Taskmaster
Wall of Souls
Dauthi Trapper
-------
Bottomless Pit
Mind Peel
Megrim

Stronhold Assassin
Crovax the Cursed
Mindwarper
Grave Pact
Revenant
Skeleton Scavengers
-------
Mortuary[/deck]

Stronghold Red
[deck]Fling
Shock
Flowstone Shambler
Flowstone Blade
Craven Giant
Mogg Flunkies
-------
Furnace Spirit
Mogg Bombers
Duct Crawler
Mob Justice

Fanning the Flames
Flame Wave
Flowstone Hellion
Convulsing Licid
Wall of Razors
Mogg Maniac
-------
Heat of Battle

Spitting Hydra
Flowstone Mauler
Invasion Plans
Shard Phoenix
Amok
Mogg Infestation
-------
Ruination[/deck]

Stronghold Green
[deck]Spike Colony
Skyshroud Troopers
Spike Worker
Spined Wurm
-------
Lowland Basilisk
Provoke
Skyshroud Archer
Overgrowth
Crossbow Ambush
Endangered Armodon
Mulch

Tempting Licid
Constant Mists
Spike Soldier
Spike Feeder
Elven Rite
Wall of Blossoms
-------
Primal Rage

Spike Breeder
Carnassid
Hermit Druid
-------
Volrath's Gardens
Awakening
Verdant Touch
Burgeoning[/deck]

Stronghold Colorless
[deck]Volrath's Stronghold
Bullwhip
Portcullis
Shifting Wall
Volrath's Laboratory
-------
Ensnaring Bridge
Hornet Cannon
Mox Diamond
Sword of the Chosen
Jinxed Ring
Horn of Greed
Heartstone[/deck]

Exodus White
[deck]Kor Chant
Shackles
Soltari Visionary
Charging Paladin
Angelic Blessing
Soul Warden
Standing Troops
-------
Reaping the Rewards
Shield Mate
Welkin Hawk
Allay

Keeper of the Light
Zealots en-Dal
Pegasus Stampede
Treasure Hunter
-------
Reconnaissance
High Ground
Peace of Mind
Penance

Exalted Dragon
Paladin en-Vec
Wall of Nets
Cataclysm
-------
Convalescence
Limited Resources
Oath of Lieges[/deck]
(Cataclysm is unplayable if you just cast it, but if you slowroll it forever in long games, float mana, cast it, and dump three guys into play it's usually pretty good.)

Exodus Blue
[deck]Merfolk Looter
Wayward Soul
Thalakos Scout
Whiptongue Frog
-------
School of Piranha
Fade Away
Theft of Dreams
Cunning
Rootwater Mystic
AEther Tide
Robe of Mirrors

Killer Whale
Scrivener
Forbid
Keeper of the Mind
-------
Curiosity
Mirozel
Treasure Trove
Mana Breach

Ephemeron
Equilibrium
Dominating Licid
Thalakos Drifters
-------
Ertai, Wizard Adept
Mind Over Matter
Oath of Scholars[/deck]

Exodus Black
[deck]Dauthi Jackal
Vampire Hounds
Death's Duet
Carnophage
Cursed Flesh
Grollub
-------
Nausea
Scare Tactics
Thrull Surgeon
Cat Burglar
Culling the Weak

Slaughter
Fugue
Dauthi Cutthroat
Dauthi Warlord
Mind Maggots
Keeper of the Dead
-------
Spike Cannibal
Necrologia

Hatred
Entropic Specter
Plaguebearer
Pit Spawn
-------
Recurring Nightmare
Oath of Ghouls
Volrath's Dungeon[/deck]

Exodus Red
[deck]Mage il-Vec
Reckless Ogre
Furnace Brood
Sonic Burst
Dizzying Gaze
-------
Anarchist
Maniacal Rage
Raging Goblin
Onslaught
Cinder Crawler
Shattering Pulse

Sabertooth Wyvern
Scalding Salamander
Keeper of the Flame
-------
Mogg Assassin
Spellshock
Flowstone Flood
Paroxysm
Price of Progress

Ogre Shaman
Seismic Assault
-------
Ravenous Baboons
Pandemonium
Monstrous Hound
Fighting Chance
Oath of Mages[/deck]

Exodus Green
[deck]Rabid Wolverines
Rootwater Alligator
Plated Rootwalla
Wood Elves
Pygmy Troll
Avenging Druid
-------
Jackalope Herd
Elvish Berserker
Predatory Hunger
Reclaim
Bequethal

Crashing Boars
Keeper of the Beasts
Spike Rogue
Cartographer
-------
Elven Palisade
Song of Serenity
Resuscitate
Skyshroud Elite

Spike Weaver
Mirri, Cat Warrior
Spike Hatcher
-------
Survival of the Fittest
Skyshroud War Beast
Manabond
Oath of Druids[/deck]

Exodus Colorless
[deck]Erratic Portal
Thopter Squadron
Transmogrifying Licid
Workhorse
Mindless Automaton
Skyshaper
-------
Coat of Arms
Null Brooch
Medicine Bag
Sphere of Resistance
City of Traitors
Memory Crystal
Spellbook[/deck]

Super useful, although it's hilarious that Oath of Druids is in the unplayable pile when you can't actually pass it ever for tix reasons. I mean I get why it's ranked purely on playability, but still.

Yeah, almost every money card is unplayable. City, Manabond, Mox, etc.

Actually mox isn't unplayable but I never go out of my way to pick it and I only would run it in certain (aggro) decks.

I would probably play Horn of Greed, am I just terrible?

Definitely. You are investing a card and likely a turn's worth of mana in an effect that will benefit your opponent first. I think of it mostly like a howling mine that costs 3 and isn't reliable.

While I can't imagine myself making great use of this any time soon, if I ever do, I'm pretty sure I'll be damn glad you posted this!

it's symmetrical :pmoteach:

I think of it as a howling mine that comes down after I've made all my early drops and immediately draws me a card that I can play that turn if it costs three or less.

What color or color combination do you think is best?

So here's the deal.

You have your Horn of Greed. You pay three mana and put it into play, and nothing happens. Then, if you have a land, you get to draw an extra card every turn. If your opponent has a land, they get to draw an extra card every turn.

Now obviously there is variance, but in general this card will benefit you and your opponent the same amount once it's in play. In fact, if anything, it will benefit your opponent more because he will have more land drops than you when you are on the play and the same number of land drops as you when you are on the draw.

But for this symmetrical effect, you paid 3 mana and a card. That is just downright awful.

I think Green is the best color, and I think White and Red are both good colors. I think Blue is marginal but has some great cards, so if I wind up playing it I'm not too broken up. I think Black is godawful and I do just about anything to avoid playing it, but I have a hard time passing things like Dark Banishing so sometimes it happens.

Generally I aim for GR.